Imagine the following situation: the architect works in Revit, the structural engineer works in Tekla, and the MEP specialists are actively using Archicad. All parties have to collaborate, but each of them uses a certain file format. At this point, the issue of BIM data exchange goes beyond simple technical concerns and becomes crucial for the entire project.
Exchange of model information does not consist only in opening somebody else's file. It implies interpretation of the geometry, properties, classification, and other parameters in the recipient model. If the exchange method is chosen incorrectly, one may have to spend several weeks on finding missing information, broken links, or incorrect visual representation of certain elements.
The key issue is formulated explicitly: exchange models in a format that is open such as IFC, work in native file formats of various software packages, or combine both methods in accordance with the specific task. There is no universal method for all situations. The choice of the best format depends on the model application.
IFC and Native Formats: What Each One Does
Industry Foundation Classes or IFC is an industry standard that allows for data interoperability among different computer applications. IFC was developed exclusively for data exchange and not for data creation. The IFC file may contain building elements, geometry, properties and relations, which makes the IFC much more than just a three-dimensional view of the structure.
That said, IFC is not a magic bullet. The exact information supported can vary depending on the software, the IFC version, and the exchange requirements defined by the project team. Two different tools may export the same model and produce files that behave differently when opened elsewhere.
RVT of Revit and PLN of Archicad are native authoring file formats. Native formats keep work in the environment of the program itself. Native files can save program-specific tools, settings, etc. This is highly convenient for teams working in one environment. If all members use Revit, the best way to share the information is in RVT files.
The weakness of native formats is the fact that they are not automatically interchangeable. The interoperability of different software means conversion or exchange of file format. The transmission of an RVT file to an Archicad user does not automatically guarantee success.
IFC vs Native Formats: Practical Trade-Offs
The comparison below highlights where each approach tends to perform well and where it demands caution.
Consideration | IFC / openBIM | Native formats |
|---|---|---|
Software compatibility | Supports cross-platform exchange, subject to software capability | Best suited to the originating software and compatible workflows |
Data and features | Exchanges agreed IFC data; some software-specific features may not transfer | Often preserves more authoring detail and platform-specific functionality |
Collaboration | Useful for multi-disciplinary teams using different tools | Efficient when participants share the same software ecosystem |
Data ownership and portability | More vendor-neutral; supports long-term access across tools | Can create dependency on particular software and versions |
Quality assurance | Requires export settings, validation, and receiving-side checks | Still requires version, permissions, and model-quality controls |
This is because of this difference: “Open” does not imply that all components transfer seamlessly; “native” does not mean that the model will be easily coordinated. IFC is the format used for exchanging data and software conformance facilitates defined subsets and workflows. This is its strength but also its weakness because some entity needs to define the contents of these subsets.
Interoperability for Multi-Disciplinary Teams
Projects in the real world are not confined to a particular software environment. The architecture, structures, MEPs, contractors, and specialized consultants will have their own authoring software for modeling. And all of these will have their own way of managing the model data. In these scenarios, BIM interoperability will face test.
Some of the roles that the IFC can play include acting as a reference model, being used in the coordination of building elements, geometry review in other platforms, and validation against properties. The IFC reference model can be provided by the architect to the MEP consultant on another platform and both will model using the authoring models.
Some friction points come along. There could be parameters that are absent or not mapped properly. The geometry could change in the process of translation. There could be classification problems. The files become huge and slow.
It is also vital to differentiate between visual alignment and data transfer. There could be a model that appears perfect in the viewer, but doesn’t possess the qualities or relations that would enable quantity take-offs, asset information, or any process following the export.
A project-specific transfer test is one of the most valuable actions which your team can undertake before starting the production process. All you have to do is to export a sample model, import it into the recipient software, analyze its properties and features, and identify any limitation issues.
When to Use IFC, Native Files, or Both
Choose native formats if the receiving team wants to edit the model in the native authoring tool, retain platform-specific content, or continue a joint native workflow. When the entire team is on the same platform, native file formats will normally provide the easiest solution.
Select IFC when the teams use different platforms, the owner requires a neutral document, the need for open BIM exists, or further use of the file should not be limited by one software. This is the reason for developing open BIM standards.
Hybrid approach is typically preferred. Native models are needed for authoring while IFC is required for collaboration, review, exchange, or transfer. Quite many projects have been implemented using both formats simultaneously, following certain priorities depending on deliverable type.
Remember that BIM interoperability is a process. Agreeing on what information to exchange and checking the results matters as much as selecting the file extension. IFC support is not a guarantee that all software handles every part of the specification identically.
When to Mandate IFC Deliverables in a Contract
Use of IFC only needs to happen when there is a need for the specific project; otherwise, it should not replace the native model automatically. “IFC submission” without any explanation can actually lead to confusion and complications.
One case where use of IFC makes sense would be when there are multiple disciplines involved or there are multiple suppliers using multiple authoring tools. Another scenario where use of IFC would make sense would be when the owner requires an independent model for some reason. Where there are public sector requirements or when the information management plan includes openBIM as a deliverable, IFC would be required.
Contract requirements to define include:
Purpose and use. State whether IFC is for reference, coordination, review, information handover, or another use.
Version and exchange requirements. Provide the required version of IFC, as well as any needed view or definition of the exchange.
Information scope. List required geometry, classifications, properties, and asset data. Avoid vague instructions such as "submit a complete IFC."
Model responsibility. Identify who exports, checks, approves, and corrects each deliverable.
Acceptance criteria. Develop quantitative controls such as open file, presence of elements, completeness of properties, and tolerance of coordination.
Native-file expectations. State whether native files are also required and which deliverable governs if files differ.
Testing and change control. Require a sample exchange early and document software versions, export settings, and issue resolution.
Contract clarity helps prevent disputes over what "IFC compliant" actually means for a particular project. It also gives the receiving team a fair basis for accepting or rejecting deliverables.
Making the Exchange Decision Work for the Project
Native file formats can be most effective for authoring inside the software environment. The IFC format can be used for neutral and platform-independent exchange of BIM information. There is no universal solution that would be better than another one, and considering only one as default goes against the nature of how construction projects operate.
This interoperability depends on requirements of information, testing of exports, and quality control. Choosing the format without this process will not facilitate coordination of the project.
The critical information that has to be understood prior to commencing the project is who needs the model, what does he need from the model, and how will the model be validated by the receiving party. This conversation has to happen prior to exporting the model and not when the first import problem arises. BIM Services can help you establish the model, IFC export testing, coordination, and validation of deliverables.
The format is a tool. The use case is the decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the difference between IFC and a native BIM format?
IFC is an open standard for exchanging BIM information across software. Native formats such as RVT and PLN are tied to their authoring applications and may preserve more platform-specific content.
2. Does IFC work with Revit and Archicad?
IFC is compatible with both Revit and Archicad, but the extent of data saved or read may differ depending on software, version, and how it was exported. Do a test exchange to be sure.
3. Does IFC guarantee that no BIM data will be lost?
Not necessarily. Even though IFC makes sure the data exchange is done in an orderly way, software and mapping might affect the geometric information and properties. You need to specify your data needs and verify the receiving file.
4. Should a project require IFC and native files?
Yes, the project might require the use of both native files and IFC for modeling and exchange purposes respectively. Ensure your contract includes the uses of each file type.
5. When should IFC be mandated in a BIM contract?
Use the IFC when different software platforms are used in the project, neutral models are needed by the owner or openBIM exchange is required by project requirements. Specify IFC version, scope of information, deadlines and validation criteria.
6. How can BIM coordinators improve IFC interoperability?
Pre-determine exchange requirements, test sample export/import, check for correct geometry/property values, determine limitations and settings, and follow standardized review and issue tracking process.
Do you need assistance in ensuring that there is an efficient workflow for BIM data exchange processes in your next project? CAD Drafting Services will facilitate model setup, test IFC export, coordinate multi-disciplines, and validate deliverables so that your team can concentrate on designing.
