It is safe to say that estimating in construction projects has always been a kind of gamble. Contractors have traditionally used manual takeoffs using 2D drawings, spreadsheets that are unable to withstand heavy loads, and a lot of guesses to estimate construction projects. The problem with all this is that when their estimates were wrong, it had a negative effect on the entire project. Budgets were exceeded, subcontractors were unhappy, and bids were lost because of inaccuracies in the quantity data. Quantity takeoffs based on BIM models change all this because now contractors are getting access to accurate quantities taken right out of the intelligent 3D models.
It is not about technology but more about the approach to cost estimation, material procurement, and project bidding processes. When you combine BIM quantity takeoffs with BIM estimating, you get a loop that allows for automatic updating of quantities whenever there are changes in the design without spending many hours on updating estimates. This gives a competitive advantage to contractors.
What BIM-Based Quantity Takeoff Actually Means
Quantity takeoff using BIM is all about deriving the number and volume of material quantities, counts, and measurements from a building information model. In contrast to conventional quantity takeoff, where the user manually measures and counts symbols from drawings, BIM quantity takeoff extracts data from elements in the model that are intelligent enough to know about themselves in terms of the information they carry. A wall element in the BIM model is intelligent enough to know its length, height, thickness, and composition material.
Several processes are involved in providing services for BIM quantity takeoff. One such process involves model conditioning, in which the model itself will be prepared to extract the data correctly. This is followed by the process of actually extracting the data through the use of software, and the outcome of this process is the generation of a quantity takeoff report categorized based on levels, categories, and systems; finally, the process of validating the extracted data takes place.
These output quantities are directly fed into the BIM cost estimation process and the BIM material takeoff process. The contractors get their quantities, which they can immediately price and submit their bids within a very short period. This is especially important in case there are several contractors bidding for the same project.
Why Traditional Estimating Falls Short
There are definite shortcomings to manual takeoffs, which tend to be quite evident when working on commercial projects. The first one would certainly be human error. When one person counts several hundred outlets and calculates areas of walls, mistakes tend to happen. One missing fitting, an incorrect calculation of the ductwork area, and your bill will have to reflect the mistake.
Beyond accuracy, manual takeoffs are slow. On a large project, a full takeoff can take weeks. During that time, design changes may occur, which means portions of the takeoff need to be redone. This creates a cycle of rework that frustrates estimators and delays bid submissions. Contractors who rely on manual methods often find themselves at a disadvantage when competing against firms that use BIM estimating services to turn around accurate estimates in days rather than weeks.
Consistency is another problem that arises from time to time. Divergent interpretations from different estimators when analyzing drawings result in inconsistent quantities. The BIM approach solves this problem because it employs a consistent extraction process.
How BIM Improves Estimating Accuracy
Accuracy improvements in the quantity takeoff process using BIM technology result from various factors. First of all, a model becomes a single source of information. If the architect makes a change in wall type or the engineer moves a mechanical run, then this change will be included in the model. If the model is synchronized with the estimator tool, then the quantities are updated automatically.
Secondly, BIM models have more information than 2D drawings. While a 2D drawing would indicate the door schedule with some dimensions, a BIM model can include fire ratings, hardware set, and installation requirements. This additional information enables the estimator to prepare a more accurate cost estimate by incorporating all information necessary for cost estimation.
Third, information about collision detection and coordination generated through BIM can be useful when doing estimates. Once the clashes have been detected and solved in the model, the quantity represents the end result of coordination and not some sort of design that is impossible to construct. This minimizes the chances of making any changes during the construction phase.
The Role of BIM Estimating Services
BIM estimation services involve the analysis of quantities derived from BIM modeling and then applying the cost details to provide an estimate. BIM estimation services not only include the process of quantity derivation but also factor in things like labor costs, material costs, equipment needs, and productivity considerations.
An important benefit that comes with BIM estimates is the possibility to perform scenario analysis. For example, contractors may want to know how changing the materials (for instance, from steel studs to concrete block) will impact the cost, or whether prefab solutions will impact the estimate. Such scenario analysis becomes possible quickly and accurately due to the direct connection of the quantities with the model.
The process of value engineering becomes achievable with the implementation of the cost estimating software that uses BIM. Where there are cases of over-budget projects, the estimators can discover from the model areas where costs can be reduced without reducing the performance of the building.
BIM Material Takeoff and Procurement
The BIM material takeoff is similar to the quantity takeoff in some ways; however, it emphasizes the materials that must be acquired. The materials include pipes, fittings, valves, ducts, conduits, wires, insulation, and many others. An accurate takeoff for the materials is necessary, as it determines what should be ordered.
It will be possible for the contractor to order the material without the fear of over-ordering and under-ordering because the material takeoff will be done using the coordinated BIM model; once in such a case, the takeoff will be done using the final design of the project after all the conflicts have been sorted out. This implies that the risk of incurring extra costs as a result of over-ordering and under-ordering of the materials will not arise at all.
The use of the BIM material takeoff will facilitate the prefabrication of the components, as the contractor will know the exact materials that will be used and their method of installation.
Integrating BIM Quantity Takeoff with MEP Coordination
MEP systems for commercial buildings constitute a major percentage of construction cost. Mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems are complex, dense, and often create clashes resulting in higher expenses. Integration of BIM quantity takeoff and MEP coordination ensures that the quantities of MEPs are correct, and thus the estimate incorporates a coordinated design.
MEP coordination services utilize BIM to detect and fix clashes prior to the construction process. After the completion of MEP coordination, the models become ready for construction without any clashes. Thus, BIM quantity takeoff services can extract quantities from the coordinated models. It helps to eliminate the gap existing between design, coordination, and estimating, which often creates surprises for contractors.
These benefits are enormous. Firstly, there will be accurate quantities of MEP systems that reflect the actual condition. Secondly, prefabrication of MEP systems is possible. Thirdly, estimates offered by the contractor will be valid for the period of construction. Fourthly, there will be minimal change orders.
Practical Workflow for BIM-Based Estimating
The process of using BIM for quantity takeoff and estimation must follow an orderly process. First, the BIM requirements have to be defined in the contract, and the LOD necessary for accurate takeoff must be specified. This LOD has to be 300 or higher to facilitate quantity takeoff.
Finally, the quantity estimators have to gain access to the BIM and the tools to extract quantities. These could be special takeoff software that works together with the BIM authoring software or could export the quantities to the quantity estimation software.
The step of validation is very important. It will be necessary to validate extracted values with respect to project requirements, previous data, and any benchmarks that may exist. It will help to find any inconsistencies and resolve them before completing the estimation process.
To conclude, it is vital to mention that updating the estimation should be provided throughout all the stages of the project development process. It will be possible to update both the model and the estimation when any changes appear.
Common Challenges and How to Overcome Them
Notwithstanding all benefits, BIM quantity takeoff is prone to certain challenges. The primary one is a poor-quality model. Poor structuring and incorrect categorization of elements will result in difficulties in quantities extraction. This problem can be resolved with the implementation of modeling standards and regular model audits.
The second issue is related to software compatibility. Different departments have different BIM authoring software, and exchanging quantities among different platforms could be quite difficult. Nevertheless, the usage of neutral formats or an integrated platform can resolve the issue, but this issue should still be taken into account.
Cultural resistance could be another difficulty. Estimators are used to doing things the way they did before; thus, they do not want to try something new. But it will be easy to overcome this resistance because of good results.
The Bottom Line for Contractors
Quantity takeoff from Building Information Modeling (BIM) is not just another useful option now. It is turning into a must for contractors willing to fight for commercial contracts that are becoming more and more complicated. With accuracy improvements, time savings, and integration with other processes in estimating and purchasing, BIM-based quantity takeoff becomes a highly effective instrument of margin protection and contract acquisition.
The amalgamation of BIM quantity takeoff, BIM estimate service, BIM cost estimation, and BIM material takeoff creates a comprehensive approach to the cost management of projects that starts right from the design stage and runs throughout the whole construction process. With this, contractors can be competitive in the marketplace.
Ready to improve your estimating accuracy with BIM?
Then connect with CAD Drafting Services and get quality BIM quantity takeoff, BIM estimating, and BIM material takeoff services for your commercial projects.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are BIM quantity takeoff services and how do they improve estimating accuracy?
Quantity Takeoffs by BIM services involve extracting quantities of materials, counts, and dimensions from the intelligent 3D models. The data is drawn from the 3D models and not from manual measurements; therefore, it is always more accurate, consistent, and up-to-date.
How early should contractors implement BIM-based estimating on a project?
Ideally, BIM-based estimating should begin at the schematic design stage and proceed right up to the construction document stage. Early involvement will enable the estimator to help influence design, find cost drivers, and give feedback on how to improve the model's effectiveness.
What deliverables should contractors expect from BIM estimating services?
These include such things as quantity schedules, estimates with pricing, takeoffs of materials, and scenarios. Some companies will even help you with prefabrication, procurement lists, and maintenance of estimates as the design progresses.
Can BIM quantity takeoff support prefabrication and modular construction?
Yes. Accurate material takeoffs from BIM models provide the data needed to prefabricate components off-site. This improves quality, reduces on-site labor, and shortens schedules. The takeoff becomes the basis for prefabrication orders and assembly planning.
How does BIM cost estimation differ from traditional estimating?
The cost estimation in BIM employs data obtained from the model to make estimations, whereas conventional cost estimation utilizes manual takeoffs from two-dimensional drawings. The former is quick, precise, and simple to revise in case any modifications in the design happen, unlike the latter.
Is BIM-based quantity takeoff effective for retrofit and tenant improvement projects?
Yes. In retrofits, the process typically begins with the scan-to-BIM process, where the current state of affairs is captured and modeled. Quantities can thus be derived for new construction, and estimations can be done with certainty. The most notable advantage of this in occupied buildings lies in the need for precision.
